INVESTIGATIVE REPORT — “How a Choir Became the Cover: The Hidden Trafficking Network Operating in Plain Sight at Stonebriar Church”
A smear campaign inside a church choir, leadership misguidedly trusting an enabler, and a survivor silenced. New preliminary findings reveal how traffickers used Stonebriar’s choir as the perfect cover — without most members ever knowing.
DALLAS, TX—Most of the Stonebriar choir had no idea what was happening around them. They sang faithfully, attended rehearsals, memorized lyrics, wore their robes, and showed up early on Sundays.
But inside that same choir loft — and throughout the lobby of the church — a small group of people were not there to worship.
They were there to procure.
They were there to recruit.
And they were there to silence the one person who recognized exactly what they were.
What follows is not an indictment of the choir — most people were innocent, unaware, and blindsided.
This is an indictment of the small number of people who enabled traffickers, and of the leadership decisions that unintentionally protected those doing harm.
1. Traffickers Blended Into Choir Culture — and No One Noticed
Stonebriar’s choir was large, warm, and trusting — the perfect environment for bad actors to blend in. Choir members did not suspect that fellow singers could be involved in anything sinister, especially something as dark as trafficking.
But traffickers often:
- Embed themselves in church ministries
- Use volunteer positions to gain legitimacy
- Exploit trusting church communities for access and recruitment
While most of the choir was simply worshiping, a small handful of individuals were networking with traffickers, spreading information, and participating in activities that others assumed were harmless or unrelated.
This set the stage for the deeper manipulation that unfolded.
2. The Smear Campaign: A Fake Facebook Page Designed to Destroy
One choir member, David, created not one but two Facebook profiles using his own name.
Then, one day, he renamed one of them with Victoria’s name.
He turned his account into an impersonation page pretending to be her.
He:
- Added stock photos of strippers and sex workers as the profile image
- Uploaded items from Victoria’s real page to make it look legitimate
- Weaponized the page to make Victoria look like she was living a double life
- Posted vulgar comments toward other choir members during rehearsals, triggering outrage directed at her
Because David was already “friends” with many choir members through that page before changing its name, it appeared to them as though Victoria was sending those comments.
So while Victoria sat quietly with her choir folder in her lap, two older women sitting a couple rows below her, turned around to look at her angrily and said,
“Look! She did it again!”
— referring to a malicious comment David had just posted.
Victoria didn’t even have her phone in her hand.
But David — sitting smugly nearby — did.
This was character assassination, calculated and deliberate.
3. Choir Members Finally Caught David — but Too Late
A couple men in the choir eventually caught David with the fake page open on his phone.
They confronted him at a choir rehearsal.
They forced him to deactivate it.
They called Victoria afterward and said:
“We didn’t know David had this problem.”
They also confronted David about an alleged pornography addiction — something they said contributed to his obsession with Victoria.
Even an undercover officer later confirmed he caught David with the fake page open on his phone in the church lobby.
Despite all this evidence, the damage had already been done.
The smear campaign worked exactly as intended.
4. Leadership Believed the Impersonator — and Fired the Survivor
When leadership met with Victoria to remove her from the choir, they cited two reasons:
- The Christmas video incident
- The fake Facebook page
(See Article: Crying in the Choir Was Misunderstood)
When Victoria explained the page was not hers and that David created it, the choir directors refused to believe her and said:
“David would never do that.”
They refused to listen.
They refused to investigate.
They refused to even consider that they had believed the wrong person.
Meanwhile, the real perpetrator:
- Was never disciplined
- Remained in the choir
- Continued influencing others
- Was caught multiple times with the impersonation page
Leadership’s choice to trust the wrong person didn’t just protect an abuser — it marginalized a survivor.
The traffickers couldn’t have asked for a more perfect outcome.
5. The Choir Didn’t Know — But Silence Made a Cover
The tragedy is not that the choir helped traffickers intentionally.
It’s that they didn’t know what they didn’t know.
Most choir members were:
- Kind
- Sincere
- Devoted to ministry
- Completely unaware predators were in their midst
But silence, confusion, and misplaced trust made the choir — unintentionally — the perfect cover.
While members sang songs of worship, a trafficking network manipulated relationships, built influence, and spread lies behind the scenes.
This is how trafficking thrives in churches:
Not through wicked congregations —
but through blind spots, trust, and denial.
6. The Truth Finally Emerged — But Only After Damage Was Done
The truth was eventually uncovered:
- Choir members caught David with the page
- An officer confirmed it.
- Survivors spoke out
- Patterns were exposed
But by then:
- The smear campaign succeeded
- Leadership decisions had already been made
- The traffickers’ goals were met
- A survivor had been discredited and pushed out
In the end, the traffickers achieved exactly what they wanted:
- The survivor was discredited,
- The enabler was protected,
- And the operation inside the church remained shielded by confusion and denial.
Not because leadership intentionally protected traffickers —
but because they trusted the wrong person, and distrusted the right one.
And this is why the story must be told now.
The choir didn’t knowingly protect traffickers.
But the systems around them —
secrecy, misplaced trust, resistance to accountability, and denial —
created the perfect shield for predators.
This article is for every church that believes “it could never happen here.”
It can.
It did.
It must never happen again.
CONCLUSION
The choir was not the villain.
Traffickers were.
But the failure to listen to a survivor, investigate wrongdoing, or question a respected member created an environment where the traffickers’ smear campaign worked flawlessly.
This is the lesson for churches everywhere:
Traffickers don’t need darkness.
They only need silence.
How Readers Can Respond: Next Steps For Those Who Wish To Engage Thoughtfully 
Support Victoria’s Restoration Fund
Learn more about how you can stand with Victoria: Standing With Victoria
Read about The Trafficking Issue at Stonebriar Church
Stonebriar Church in Frisco, TX
Stonebriar Community Church is an Evangelical traditional style church located in the Dallas Fort Worth Metroplex at 4801 Legendary Dr, Frisco, TX 75034. The pastor of Stonebriar Church at the time of this incident was founding pastor Chuck Swindoll, who retired in October 2024. Chuck Swindoll is an evangelical Christian pastor, author, educator, and radio preacher. He founded Insight for Living, and is chancellor emeritus at Dallas Theological Seminary. Jonathan Murphy is the current senior pastor of Stonebriar Church. The church website is: https://www.stonebriar.org
